To The Point

The main objectives of the Industrial Policy of the Government in India are:

• to maintain a sustained growth in productivity;
• to enhance gainful employment;
• to achieve optimal utilisation of human resources;
• to attain international competitiveness; and
• to transform India into a major partner and player in the global arena.

Industrial Policies in India since Independence

• Industrial Policy Resolution of 1948- It defined the broad contours of the policy delineating the role of the State in industrial development both as an entrepreneur and authority.
  
  • It made clear that India is going to have a Mixed Economic Model.
  • It classified industries into four broad areas:
    
    • Strategic Industries (Public Sector): It included three industries in which Central Government had monopoly. These included Arms and ammunition, Atomic energy and Rail transport.
    • Basic/Key Industries (Public-cum-Private Sector): 6 industries viz. coal, iron & steel, aircraft manufacturing, ship-building, manufacture of telephone, telegraph & wireless apparatus, and mineral oil were designated as “Key Industries” or “Basic Industries”.
      
      • These industries were to be set-up by the Central Government.
      • However, the existing private sector enterprises were allowed to continue.
      • These industries continue to remain under private sector however, the central government, in consultation with the state government, had general control over them.
      • It was regarded as the “Economic Constitution of India” or “The Bible of State Capitalism”.
      • The 1956 Policy empha­sised the need to expand the public sector, to build up a large and growing coop­erative sector and to encourage the separation of ownership and management in private in­dustries and, above all, prevent the rise of pri­vate monopolies.
      • It provided the basic framework for the government’s policy in regard to in­dustries till June 1991.
      • IPR, 1956 classified industries into three categories
        
        • Schedule A consisting of 17 industries was the exclusive responsibility of the State. Out of these 17 industries, four industries, namely arms and ammunition, atomic en­ergy, railways and air transport had Central Government monopolies; new units in the remaining industries were developed by the State Governments.
        • Schedule B, consisting of 12 industries, was open to both the private and public sectors; however, such industries were progressively State-owned.
        • Schedule C- All the other industries not included in these two Schedules constituted the third category which was left open to the pri­vate sector. However, the State reserved the right to undertake any type of indus­trial production.
        • The sector was kept under state control through a system of licenses.

        Industrial Licenses

        • In order to open new industry or to expand production, obtaining a license from the government was a prerequisite.
        • Opening new industries in economically backward areas was incentivised through easy licensing and subsidization of critical inputs like electricity and water. This was done to counter regional disparities that existed in the country.
        • Licenses to increase production were issued only if the government was convinced that the economy required more of the goods.
        • Industrial Policy Statement, 1977- In December 1977, the Janata Government announced its New Industrial Policy through a statement in the Parliament.
          
          • The main thrust of this policy was the effective promotion of cottage and small industries widely dispersed in rural areas and small towns.
          • In this policy the small sector was classified into three groups—cottage and household sector, tiny sector and small scale industries.
          • The 1977 Industrial Policy prescribed different areas for large scale industrial sector- Basic industries,Capital goods industries, High technology industries and Other industries outside the list of reserved items for the small scale sector.
          • The 1977 Industrial Policy restricted the scope of large business houses so that no unit of the same business group acquired a dominant and monopolistic position in the market.
          • It put emphasis on reducing the occurrence of labour unrest. The Government encouraged the worker’s participation in management from shop floor level to board level.
          • Criticism: The industrial Policy 1977, was subjected to serious criticism as there was an absence of effective measures to curb the dominant position of large scale units and the policy did not envisage any socio­economic transformation of the economy for curbing the role of big business houses and multinationals.

          New Industrial Policy During Economic Reforms of 1991

          The long-awaited liberalised industrial policy was announced by the Government of India in 1991 in the midst of severe economic instability in the country. The objective of the policy was to raise efficiency and accelerate economic growth.

          Features of New Industrial Policy

          • De-reservation of Public sector: Sectors that were earlier exclusively reserved for public sector were reduced. However, pre-eminent place of public sec­tor in 5 core areas like arms and ammu­nition, atomic energy, mineral oils, rail transport and mining was continued.
            
            • Presently, only two sectors- Atomic Energy and Railway operations- are reserved exclusively for the public sector.
            • There are only 4 industries at present related to security, strategic and environmental concerns, where an industrial license is currently required-
              
              • Electronic aerospace and defence equipment
              • Specified hazardous chemicals
              • Industrial explosives
              • Cigars and cigarettes of tobacco and manufactured tobacco substitutes
              • Today, there are numerous sectors in the economy where government allows 100% FDI.

              Outcomes of New Industrial Policies

              • The 1991 policy made ‘Licence, Permit and Quota Raj’ a thing of the past. It attempted to liberalise the economy by removing bureaucratic hurdles in industrial growth.
              • Limited role of Public sector reduced the burden of the Government.
              • The policy provided easier entry of multinational companies, privatisation, removal of asset limit on MRTP companies, liberal licensing.
                
                • All this resulted in increased competition, that led to lower prices in many goods such as electronics prices. This brought domestic as well as foreign investment in almost every sector opened to private sector.

                Limitations of Industrial Policies in India

                • Stagnation of Manufacturing Sector: Industrial policies in India have failed to push manufacturing sector whose contribution to GDP is stagnated at about 16% since 1991.
                • Distortions in industrial pattern owing to selective inflow of investments: In the current phase of investment following liberalisation, while substantial investments have been flowing into a few industries, there is concern over the slow pace of investments in many basic and strategic industries such as engineering, power, machine tools, etc.
                • Displacement of labour: Restructuring and modernisation of industries as a sequel to the new industrial policy led to displacement of labour.
                • Absence of incentives for raising efficiency: Focussing attention on internal liberalisation without adequate emphasis on trade policy reforms resulted in ‘consumption-led growth’ rather than ‘investment’ or ‘export-led growth’.
                • Vaguely defined industrial location policy: The New Industrial Policy, while emphasised the detrimental effects of damage to the environment, failed to define a proper industrial location policy, which could ensure a pollution free development of industrial climate.

                Way Forward

                • Industrial policies in India have taken a shift from predominantly Socialistic pattern in 1956 to Capitalistic since 1991.
                • India now has a much liberalised industrial policy regime focusing on increased foreign investment and lesser regulations.
                • India ranked 77th on World Bank’s Doing Business Report 2018. Reforms related to insolvency resolution (Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, 2017) and the Goods and Services Taxes (GST) are impressive and will result in long-term gains for the industrial sector.
                • Campaigns such as Make in India and Start up India have helped to enhance the business ecosystem in the country.
                • However, electricity shortages and high prices, credit constraints, high unit labour costs due to labour regulations, political interference and other regulatory burdens continue to remain challenges for firm growth of the industrial sector in India.
                • There is a need for a new Industrial Policy to boost the manufacturing sector in the country. Government in December 2018 also felt the need to introduce a new Industrial Policy that would be a road map for all business enterprises in the country.